Teach for Australia (TFA) has abjectly failed to answer criticisms of the program. Save Our Schools has criticised TFA on several grounds:
• The large majority of its teachers are in marginally disadvantaged schools instead of highly disadvantaged schools;
• Its attrition rate is very much higher than for traditionally-trained early career teachers;
• The high turnover of TFA teachers imposes additional financial and human resource costs on schools and negatively impacts on disadvantaged students;
• It is a very high cost program in comparison with traditional teacher training; and
• There is no substantive evidence that TFA teachers improve student results more than traditionally trained teachers. Continue reading “Pathetic Response by Teach for Australia to Criticisms”
An evaluation report on the fast-track teacher training program, Teach for Australia (TFA), raises serious questions about the effectiveness of the program. It shows that TFA teachers are not being placed in genuinely disadvantaged schools and a high proportion leave teaching within three years of completing the program. It calls for changes to increase retention such as longer placement lengths, or incentives for TFA teachers to stay in disadvantaged classrooms. There are also serious questions about the cost effectiveness of TFA and its impact on student outcomes.
Continue reading “Teach for Australia Fails in its Mission”
Emeritus Professor of Education at Stanford University, Larry Cuban, offers the principles that have guided his thinking and actions as a practitioner, scholar, and blogger about teaching, learning, and school reform. Professor Cuban has published extensively on the history of curriculum and teaching, educational leadership, school reform and the uses of technology in classrooms. This article was originally published on the 8th anniversary of his blog School Reform and Classroom Practice and is reprinted with permission. Continue reading “Guiding Principles for School Reform and Classroom Practice”
There was much wringing of hands at the continuing decline
in Australia’s reading, mathematics and science results revealed by the results
from the OECD’s Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) published
last December. Unfortunately, there was little in the way of constructive
analysis of the factors behind the declines.
Continue reading “Australia Has High Quality Teaching but Too Much Out-of-Field Teaching”
Competition and choice policies in education are leading to the de-professionalization of teaching. A policy brief published by the US National Education Policy Centre titled Reversing the Deprofessionalization of Teaching says that it is being driven by fast-track teacher preparation, teacher evaluation based on student test scores and the use of scripted, narrow curricula.
Continue reading “The De-Professionalization of Teaching”
School teaching is a craft. A school teacher is
an adult in a room full of children and the task is to look after the children,
supervise their social behaviour, and give them skills and knowledge.
When I use the word ‘craft’, I don’t mean making things out of seashells. I mean an activity that
involves using skill to achieve a practical end. You learn how to teach by
doing it. Parenting skills are probably the most valuable skills to have. There
are many teaching methods and every teaching situation is different, so a
teacher needs to have many techniques and must constantly be thinking about
which ones to use.
Continue reading “Reflections on Teaching: The Craft of Teaching”
Surveys of beginning teachers by the Australian Secondary Principals’ Association in the middle years of the last decade provided conclusive data that teacher trainees valued very highly their experiences in schools prior to graduation, in many cases finding this more useful than some of the experiences in their tertiary institutions. So, principals have a significant responsibility in making this experience as valuable as possible, especially as we want high quality teachers in every classroom in every school. Continue reading “Principal Leadership Makes Teacher Training Effective”
Despite working longer hours and facing more challenging circumstances than teachers in many other countries, Australian teachers report high job satisfaction and strong self-belief about their ability to help students learn. However, they need to be better supported by the community in the challenging job they do on behalf of society.
These results come from the Teaching and Learning International Survey, recently published by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). It provides a detailed picture of the experiences of lower secondary teachers across 34 countries, including 24 OECD countries. Continue reading “Australian Teachers Work Longer Hours and Face More Challenges Than Teachers in Many Countries”
An evaluation of Teach for Australia carried out by the Australian Council for Educational Research (ACER) shows that it is a very high cost program but fails to demonstrate that it has improved school outcomes or teacher retention in disadvantaged schools.
The cost of training TFA associates vastly exceeds that of traditional university-based training. Retention of TFA teachers is well below that of mainstream teaching graduates and a significant proportion of those who remain in teaching transfer out of disadvantaged schools. There is no robust evidence that TFA teachers are more successful in improving student results in disadvantaged schools than university-trained teachers. Continue reading “Teach for Australia is Not Cost-effective”
A guest column by a school principal on the ‘hare-brained’ teacher appraisal scheme introduced by the Victorian Government. Continue reading “The Victorian Government is Floundering in Education”