Undeclared family income – most of it from grandparents – is inflating Commonwealth funding to private schools by at least $1.5 billion a year.
Private schools are being overfunded by about $1.5 billion a year because many grandparents pay school fees for their grandchildren. It is the tip of the overfunding iceberg because recent surveys show that grandparents – the Bak of Mum and Dad – provide billions in undeclared income to their adult children in a myriad of ways other than paying school fees. The overfunding demands a complete overhaul of how private schools are funded. It should be subjected to an independent public review.
The overfunding occurs because income not declared by families is not included in the measure used to calculate Commonwealth Government funding of private schools. Government funding is determined by the capacity to contribute (CTC) score of a school which is based on the median adjusted taxable income of families with children in a school.
Commonwealth Government funding of private schools is overestimated because taxable family income does not capture undeclared gifts of income and other financial assistance from the Bank of Mum and Dad.
It is widely acknowledged that many grandparents contribute money to families to pay school fees or even pay them directly to schools. It is a fact acknowledge by many private schools.
A report on the cost of education in Australia in 2026 by the education bonds company Futurity Investment Group found that 57% of parents received financial support from other family members, mainly grandparents, to meet the cost of educating their children. Research by Resolve Strategic reported by The Agefound that grandparents contributed an average of $1,676 annually towards education costs for children in Victorian Catholic schools and $5,593 for children in independent schools.
Independent Schools Australia (ISA) have revealed that 20% of families in Independent schools receive financial support from other family members to pay school fees. In July, the principal of Xavier College in Melbourne said that the school is aware that grandparents in the school community assist with fees. Two Sydney elite private schools have admitted that many grandparents paid the school fees for students. At another Sydney Independent school half of all fee invoices are sent directly to grandparents.
The Australian Financial Review recently reported an instance of a grandparent setting up a trust for each of his grandchildren to pay for their school fees. This has the double advantage that payments to charities such as schools are tax exempt.
The headline overfunding estimate is based on a worked example of a secondary school with a CTC score of 100 and median family income of approximately $170,000. The school would qualify for base funding of $13,119 per student in 2025. The calculation assumes grandparents contribute an average of $4,000 per student towards school fees. If this assistance were incorporated into family-resource assessments, the school’s CTC score could rise to 101, 102 or higher.
At a CTC score of 102, the school would receive $12,350 per student, indicating overfunding of $769 per student if the income from grandparents were included in the assessment. Extrapolating the $769 overfunding across 2,533 private secondary schools with an average enrolment of 1,000 students gives a total overfunding figure o $1.5 billion.
Overfunding is likely to be higher for schools where grandparents make larger fee contributions than the figure used here. This is likely for schools with higher CTC scores where fees are generally greater than for schools with lower CTC scores.
This is just a ballpark estimate, but it indicates the potential impact on government funding of private schools if payments of school fees by the Bank of Mum and Dad were considered. It is also a very conservative estimate because it ignores all the other income received from the Bank of Mum and Dad.
Other recent surveys have highlighted the extent of income provided to families by grandparents in addition to contributing to private school fees.
A survey by the Special Broadcasting Service (SBS estimated that older Australians provide more than $140 billion in everyday financial support for their adult children each year. More than 12 million Australians reportedly provide financial help, including cash, groceries, clothing, debt repayments, travel and purchases of major items.
Other surveys highlight the scale of intergenerational assistance in the housing market. Australian Unity recently reported average contributions of $75,800 towards first-home purchases by adult children, with considerably larger amounts among wealthier grandparents. The financial services firm Finder found that 30% cent of homeowners had received family assistance to purchase property. Money.com reported that 46% of Australians buying their first home in the previous 12 months had received help from the Bank of Mum and Dad. The average cash gift was $53,451and 23% of recipients were gifted more than $100,000.
All this suggests that the estimated overfunding of private schools due to grandparents paying school fees is just the tip of the overfunding iceberg. Based on SBS research, this may amount to billions of dollars per year for private school families.
There is also another basic flaw in the private school funding model that exacerbates the overfunding. The model ignores billions in income received by private schools in the form of donations, dividends from financial investments, income received from the hire of facilities such as swimming pools and theatres as well as rental income from properties owned by schools. This income of hundreds of millions is ignored in determining Commonwealth funding of private schools.
The Productivity Commission estimated that donations to school building funds alone were almost $800 million in 2021. The donations were heavily concentrated in a small number of elite private schools with 10% of schools receiving about 80% of total donations. This makes nonsense of any claim that high fee private schools are funded according to need. Moreover, there is an incentive for families to arrange to provide donations in lieu of paying fees because donations to schools with charitable status are tax deductible.
The system of funding private schools clearly fails to accurately accounts for the resources available to schools and their families. It results in massive overfunding or private schools and a huge waste of taxpayer resources. Funding is not fully based on need. It presents a challenge to the Albanese Government to acknowledge these flaws It presents a compelling case for an independent public review of the system of funding private schools to eliminate this waste.
This article was originally published on Pearls and Irritatioins.