Public Education Needs a Level Playing Field to Flourish – A Reply to Save Our Schools

Tom Greenwell & Chris Bonnor

Trevor Cobbold and Save Our Schools have made a welcome and vigorous response to our proposal for a common framework for all Australian schools. The essence of the common framework is that all schools should be eligible for full needs-based public funding as long as they don’t charge fees and they do adopt inclusive enrolment practices.


Firstly, it is important to note an essential area of agreement: a deep shared commitment to public education understood as “publicly owned, publicly governed and publicly accountable secular institutions operating under universal social obligations.” This form of education embodies values of solidarity and fairness, citizenship and community that are an essential part of a good society, and it urgently needs to be promoted and strengthened.

Continue reading “Public Education Needs a Level Playing Field to Flourish – A Reply to Save Our Schools”

Don’t Destroy Public Edcation in the Name of Reform

The following is a summary of a research paper by Save Our Schools. The full paper can be downloaded below.

Australia’s education debate is at a dangerous turning point. In the pursuit of greater equity, some commentators propose that private schools receive full taxpayer funding, provided they do not charge fees and relax some enrolment restrictions. Save Our Schools completely rejects this proposal as a chimera that also jettisons the foundation principles of public education.

The central question is not whether Australia needs a fairer education system. It unquestionably does. The real question is whether we strengthen public education — or dismantle its core principles.

SOS rejects full taxpayer funding of private schools for two reasons:

  • It abrogates key principles of public education; and
  • Religious and private school organisations are very unlikely to give up their resource advantage over public schools and their special funding privileges.
Continue reading “Don’t Destroy Public Edcation in the Name of Reform”

Gonski Rejected Accounting Tricks Included in Bilateral Funding Agreements

The bilateral school funding agreements between the Albanese and state/territory governments allow the states and the Northern Territory to claim several expenditures as part of their share of funding the Schooling Resource Standard (SRS) of public schools which are specifically excluded from how the SRS is estimated. The Gonski Report of 2011 rejected inclusion of these expenditures in the calculation of the SRS. They were excluded from original funding agreements that implemented the Gonski funding model in 2014 and were first introduced in the Morrison Government agreements in 2019.

These provisions allow state and Northern Territory governments to artificially boost their claimed funding shares for public schools. They can pretend they are spending more on public schools than they are in reality. The provisions allow governments to defraud public schools of legitimate SRS funding.

Continue reading “Gonski Rejected Accounting Tricks Included in Bilateral Funding Agreements”

Independent Schools Own Up to Major Flaw in the Private School Funding Model

In a extraordinary development, Independent Schools Australia (ISA) has owned up to a fundamental flaw in how government funding of its schools is estimated. A media release issued by ISA reveals that 20% of families in Independent schools receive financial support from other family members.

It is an extraordinary admission because ISA is effectively admitting that its schools are overfunded. They are overfunded because income from other family members is not included in adjusted taxable family income which is used to determine Commonwealth Government funding of private schools. The median adjusted taxable income of parents in a private school determines the capacity to contribute (CTC) score which in turn determines the base level of Commonwealth funding.

Private schools are overfunded to the extent that income from other family members leads to underestimation of adjusted taxable income and the CTC score. The higher the proportion of students who have their fees partially or wholly paid by other family members the greater the overfunding of a school. As a result, the extent of overfuding due to the Bank of Mum and Dad will vary between schools.

Continue reading “Independent Schools Own Up to Major Flaw in the Private School Funding Model”

NSW Independent Schools Enrol Very Few Low Income Students

It is fascinating to see how Independent schools and their lobby groups now resort to claiming they enrol many students from low income families as justification for their over-generous and ever increasing taxpayer funding. The latest is the claim by Independent Schools NSW that they serve the needs of lower income families. Catholic school organisations also make similar claims.

The facts are that NSW Independent and Catholic schools serve a very small proportion of low income students and only a tiny proportion of schools are disadvantaged. It is NSW public schools that serve the vast majority of low income families and nearly all disadvantaged schools in NSW are public schools. Moreover, public schools are vastly underfunded to meet the learning needs of these students while Independent and Catholic schools are very well resourced to meet the learning needs of their students.

Continue reading “NSW Independent Schools Enrol Very Few Low Income Students”

Standarised Tests and Scripted Lessons Are Failing Both Teachers and Students

Is it time to ditch scripted lessons and heavily-packed curricula to focus on individual student growth?

This is the question posed by education expert Geoff Masters, in a new book called The Children We Leave Behind. He argues that age-based expectations are not serving all children well, while scripted lessons are failing teachers and students alike.

Masters, the former head of the Australian Council for Educational Research, asks how well children are served by a system in which two pupils in the same class can differ by six or more years of learning but are taught the same material.

He argues this system fails children at either end of the scale – those who are struggling and those who are unchallenged. He asks what if, instead of holding all pupils of the same age to the same learning expectations, we based expectations on where individuals are in their comprehension and individual growth.

“Too many students in our schools are being poorly served and left behind by machineries of schooling not fit for purpose,” Masters warns.

Continue reading “Standarised Tests and Scripted Lessons Are Failing Both Teachers and Students”

Tom Greenwell Reply to SOS

Tome Greenwell,co-author of Waiting for Gonski, has submitted the following comment on t our post Canada is No Solution. The comment is published in the interest of frthering public debate on an important issue in school funding in Australia.

In Ontario around 93 percent of students attend public schools. Two thirds of these public schools are secular, while one third are faith-based. But all are fully publicly funded and completely free; and all are required to enrol students from a local enrolment zone. The socioeconomic profile of the students in the faith-based schools is almost exactly the same as those in the secular schools. Social segregation is much lower in Ontario’s schools than Australia’s. The very small fee-charging private school sector serves around 7 percent of students and receives no public funding.

Continue reading “Tom Greenwell Reply to SOS”

Canada is No Solution

The following letter was submitted to the Editor of the Sydney Morning Herald in response to an opinion piece by author Jane Caro in the Sun-Herald on 3 May. The letter was not published.

It is baffling that erstwhile advocates of public education want to jettison core principles that have governed public education for 150 years. Jane Caro’s proposal to adopt Ontario’s system of full taxpayer funding of private  schools (SMH 3 May) should be comprehensively rejected because it breaches the core principles of secular, non-discriminatory and free education.

It would introduce structural contradictions in the public system: some schools would be secular and others free to propagate a religion; some would be prohibited from discrimination in hiring staff while others would be allowed to discriminate on the basis of gender, disability, sexual orientation, transgender identity and marital status.

Full taxpayer funding of private schools is no guarantee that they would not be able to charge fees. Other countries sch as Netherlands, Belgium and New Zealand which integrate Catholic schools in the public system permit a plethora of fees, capital charges and pseudo fees in the form of so-called voluntary contributions.

Catholic and Independent schools had the chance to participate in a truly needs-based funding system designed by David Gonski. They squibbed it in favour of special funding deals. Generous government funding and fees provide Catholic schools with a significant resource advantage over public schools and a  very large advantage in the case of Independent schools. It is incomprehensible that they would give this up in the light of the Gonski experience.

It is equally incomprehensible that the Catholic bishops and education leaders y would give up the privilege of diverting government funding intended for regional and outer suburban disadvantaged schools to inner-city schools competing for  market share with wealthy Independent schools.

The direct way to reduce social segregation in schools is to stop the massive underfunding of public schools and ensure their full funding as well as end the  overfunding  of private schools.

Victorian Budget Must Fix Public School Funding Crisis

These are the key points of a new brief on the state of school funding in Victoria. The full paper can be downloaded below.

Victorian public schools face a funding crisis that must be addressed in the forthcoming Victorian Government Budget.

  • Public schools are massively underfunded and have been since the Gonski funding model was introduced in 2014 to ensure they are fully funded at the Schooling Resource Standard (SRS). In 2026, Victoria’s public schools are only funded at 86% of their SRS. Total underfunding is estimated at $2.2 billion.
  • Public schools are underfunded because of underfunding by both the Commonwealth and Victorian governments and because of “accounting tricks” used by the Victorian Government to defraud public schools
Continue reading “Victorian Budget Must Fix Public School Funding Crisis”

Resource Increases in NSW Private Schools Outstrip Public Schools

New figures show that Independent schools have a major resource advantage over Catholic and public schools in NSW. Government funding increases have favoured Catholic and Independent schools over public schools since 2009. Catholic and public schools now have similar resource levels. However, public schools remain massively underfunded for the challenges they face while Independent and Catholic schools are overfunded. The favourable funding for private schools is a key factor behind the enrolment shift to these schools.

Continue reading “Resource Increases in NSW Private Schools Outstrip Public Schools”